logo_tag
Back

US Private Flights: Operational Control Rests With Certificate Holder or Genuine Dry-Lease Lessee, Not the Invoicing Party

Why It MattersPrivate-aviation pricing and paperwork can obscure who legally operates a flight, so the certificate holder, the lease structure and the aircraft registration, not the invoicing party, determine regulatory responsibility.

BizJet Journal

What happened

Operational control is a defined concept under US regulations: authority over the initiation, conduct and termination of a flight, as set out in 14 CFR 1.1. The company named on an invoice may not be the entity legally operating the flight. A customer who chooses the itinerary or pays for a trip does not thereby become the operator of a certificated charter, and owning an aircraft does not by itself establish operational control of every flight.

US Private Flights: Operational Control Rests With Certificate Holder or Genuine Dry-Lease Lessee, Not the Invoicing Par

For a Part 135 charter, Section 135.77 places operational-control responsibility on the certificate holder, which must name its authorized operational-control personnel by name and title in its required manual. A broker may locate aircraft, arrange contracts and coordinate changes without becoming the operator. Under Section 91.3, the pilot in command has direct responsibility and final authority for the aircraft's operation, but that does not erase the certificate holder's duty to provide a compliant operation. DOT's Section 295.24 adds requirements for broker-arranged charters.

A dry lease supplies the aircraft without crew. In a genuine arrangement, the lessee normally assumes operational control and the associated operator responsibilities, as described in FAA Advisory Circular 91-37B, Truth in Leasing. The FAA's guidance for pilots, owners and operators warns of the "sham dry lease," or "wet lease in disguise," in which parties act in concert to provide an aircraft and at least one crewmember to a passenger. One example is a passenger signing two independent contracts, one for the aircraft and one for the pilot.

An illustrative comparison sets a $16,000 charter quote against linked aircraft and crew agreements totaling $13,000 (aircraft $9,000, crew $1,800, other operating costs $2,200). That is a $3,000, or 18.75%, price difference, but the figure does not indicate whether the arrangement is a lawful dry lease. The example assumes the totals cover the same trip elements and uses no actual market rates.

Before confirming a flight, customers can obtain the operating legal entity, its certificate information and the aircraft registration, and check them against the FAA's Part 135 operators and aircraft resource. If an operator or aircraft does not appear, the FAA directs users to contact the local Flight Standards District Office. For leases, parties should obtain a written allocation of operational control and check whether Section 91.23 truth-in-leasing requirements apply, which generally cover leases of US-registered large civil aircraft, subject to exceptions.

Industry impact & what to watch

The split between who sells a trip and who legally operates it is built into how charter works. Brokers, fractional programs and aircraft owners can all appear on a quote or invoice, yet regulatory responsibility follows the certificate and the allocation of operational control, not the commercial relationship. That is why price comparisons between a certificated charter and a lease-plus-crew package say little on their own: a lower total can reflect a different regulatory position as much as a different cost base.

The sham dry lease concern shows where enforcement attention concentrates. Arrangements that look like two independent contracts but function as one wet-lease service sit between Part 91 and Part 135, and the guidance treats the parties' coordination as the telling factor. Segments that rely on lease structures therefore carry documentation risk that conventional charter does not.

No pending rulemaking or enforcement action is described here, so the practical checkpoints remain the ones already in place: the operator named in the manual, the entry in the FAA's Part 135 resource, and a written statement of who holds operational control on each flight.

Original Source

Aircraft Operational Control: Who Runs Your Flight?BizJet Journal
Keep Exploring